The Karnataka High Court has set aside a fine of ₹2.9 crore imposed by the National Green Tribunal (NGT) on the Indian Army, providing relief in a case related to environmental violations.
Background:
The NGT had penalized the Indian Army for alleged violations of environmental norms at its training establishments in Karnataka. The fine was levied after claims of improper waste disposal and activities that potentially caused environmental degradation.
Court’s Rationale:
The High Court, after reviewing the case, found the penalty imposed by the NGT to be unsustainable. It ruled that there was insufficient evidence to substantiate claims of environmental harm directly attributable to the Army. The court also considered the procedural aspects, stating that due process had not been adequately followed before levying the fine.
Implications:
The ruling underscores the importance of adhering to procedural fairness in environmental enforcement actions. It also brings attention to the need for clarity in the accountability of defense establishments concerning environmental regulations.
Conclusion:
This judgment serves as a reminder that while environmental protection is critical, enforcement actions must be supported by clear evidence and due process to ensure fairness and credibility in legal proceedings.